Essay : Evaluation of Reservation System in India



(Image courtesy - https://www.cleanpng.com)

Dr. B R Ambedkar led Indian Constituency Committee, introduced reservation system in Independent India. Though this was not first time the term was introduced ( as Rajarshi Shahu Maharaj have introduced this before in Kolhapur, Maharashtra ) , it was the first time benefiting the people all across United India. Initially, the Scheduled Castes (SC) and Scheduled Tribes (ST) were subjected to benefits. After Mandal Commission identified 52% of population need to be provided positive affirmation, it has made provision for Other Backward Class (OBC) in 1987. Recently in 2019, EWS criteria has been determined for Economic Weaker Section of the society.

The reservation policy has been facing criticism and controversy, mainly after 2000. The Gujjar in Rajasthan demanding ST status from OBC, Jaats asking for their inclusion in OBC, Patidar in Gujrat, Maratha in Maharashtra, Kapu community in Andhra Pradesh. Few groups of society, who are not beneficiaries, are demanding for complete removal of reservation policy.

While evaluating the relevance of the policy on current grounds, the data shows SC, ST, OBC, Muslims are way behind social average of assets, annual income, annual spending. Even after providing reservations, they lag other forward communities in terms of education. Large masses of these people still struggle to full fill basic needs. Does that mean reservation failed to achieve its goal ? Apparently not ! 

After Independence in 1947, India has struggled to uplift these part of society. The one of the reason is its history of relations with neighbours. Post World War II while western power US and eastern power USSR were trying to get newly independent countries in Asia and Africa on their sides, Jawaharlal Nehru made decision to remain abstain and started non-alignment movement. Unfortunately, the hostile relations with Pakistan and China, who were supported in terms arms and resources by US and USSR respectively, had compelled India to spend on defense, instead of development of its people. The result is delayed in creating equal opportunity grounds for the deprived. 
 
In populous country like India, which is unable to provide high quality and affordable education to all, reservation aids this class of society to compete with privileged by providing some relaxation in qualifying cutoffs and fee waivers.However, cast based reservation deprives the under-privileged in upper caste. As reservation is meant for providing equal grounds of opportunities for all by uplifting disadvantaged group of society, the reforms are needed to define current reservation policy.


Reference:
1. Economic Times - 2011 census data for socioeconomic status of various groups.
2. Wikipedia - History of Reservation in India



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Essay : Is freebies culture promoted by political parties in nation's interest ?

Essay : How is the falling rupee impacting the Indian economy?

Suicide - A philosophical overview